I found this wonderful scene while leading a recent workshop on Cape Cod. The lead image is the one that I settled on as my favorite. I think the story of how I arrived at this image is worthy of sharing. I sent the image to my friend Dan who is my goto guy for feedback. He suggested the crop below as another possibility. Interesting, Dan tends to see in neat tidy compositions as he is prone to use his 70-200 with a 1.7x teleconverter. As such he will isolate and drill down. I like his crop!
Inspired by Dan’s thoughts, I decided to show Dan the original image I shot. Another right answer! (See below)
As you can see, my first shot and initial instinct was to include the water but then I zoomed in a bit and excluded the water. Hey, another right answer!
My hope is that this series of images drives home three important ideas. First, look for more than one right answer when you’re shooting. I could have made the first image and walked away, but I didn’t. I kept looking to see what else might be there. Second, work the composition both in the field and in post processing. There is nothing wrong with cropping your images! In fact, I think you’ll be surprised at how many other right answers you will find with the crop tool! And third, we all see differently. There is no one right answer, rather there are almost always more right answers and yours will be different than mine and that is just fine. So, stop thinking in terms of right and wrong and focus on what feels right and go with that!